• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Stacked Sandwich Shop

At Stacked Sandwich Shop, nestled in Forest Hills, NY, the love for sandwiches translates into a diverse menu brimming with flavor and creativity. Founded with a mission to elevate the humble sandwich, Stacked combines quality ingredients with a casual vibe. Signature creations like "The Stacked OG" and unique vegan options showcase their commitment to inclusivity and taste. Each bite reflects the passion of a team that prioritizes freshness and customer satisfaction. Ideal for lunch or takeout, Stacked offers a little something for everyone—from classic flavors to innovative twists. Experience the joy of sharing meals in this charming haven of deliciousness.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to the delightful world of Stacked Sandwich Shop, a celebrated gem located in the heart of Forest Hills, NY. This charming establishment has quickly become a go-to destination for sandwich enthusiasts, offering a vibrant variety of options that cater to both traditional and contemporary tastes. With a menu teeming with imaginative sandwiches, fresh salads, and even vegan delights, Stacked invites you to indulge in a casual yet satisfying dining experience.

Situated at 68-60 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, Stacked Sandwich Shop exudes a hip and welcoming vibe. It features an inviting exterior and a creatively designed menu displayed in colorful chalk, setting the stage for the indulgence to come. Their signature sandwiches—ranging in size from 6" minis to hearty 14" stacks—are crafted with the freshest ingredients and thoughtful combinations that promise to tantalize your taste buds.

  • Signature Offerings: Signature sandwiches like the Stacked OG are a must-try, with layers of salami, ham, and several cheeses, all topped with spicy chopped peppers. If you're in the mood for a unique twist, the Buffalo Blazer offers a spicy fan-favorite experience with buffalo chicken and creamy Caesar dressing.
  • Vegetarian and Vegan Options: Catering to a diverse clientele, Stacked doesn’t skimp on vegetarian and vegan offerings. Items like the Vegan Muffuletta and Chickpea Salad Sandwich have received rave reviews, proving that satisfying flavors can be found for everyone.
  • Comfortable Dining: Experience various modes of service, from casual takeout to outdoor seating. With a dog-friendly policy and garage parking, Stacked creates a convenient and laid-back atmosphere perfect for lunch breaks or leisurely afternoons.

Customer experiences at Stacked resonate with positivity. Many patrons highlight the friendliness of the staff, amplifying the sense of community that this sandwich shop fosters. While some reviews mention a desire for more classic sandwich varieties, the unique blends and specialty items certainly shine, making each visit an opportunity to try something new and exciting.

Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or utilizing their efficient delivery service, Stacked Sandwich Shop promises generous portions and flavors that truly leave an impression. With a variety of sandwiches that live up to the "stacked" name and a commitment to flavorful combinations, this vibrant eatery deserves a spot on your culinary map. So next time you find yourself around Forest Hills, do yourself a favor and visit Stacked Sandwich Shop; it’s a delicious adventure waiting to happen!

For orders, catch them at (845) 558-3535; your taste buds will thank you!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Stacked Sandwich Shop
Andrew K.
Andrew K.

Stacked is the type of sandwich shop I would really like in theory and don't get me wrong, I did enjoy the sandwich I got. But it's not a place I would put on a rotation or feel the need to come back. For one, I was super excited to find this type of establishment on Austin Street, as it really does need something like this. The place itself has a pretty hip vibe- the menu is written in colorful chalk with fun designs. I've been twice and both times have been the only person in the place, so not sure how busy it gets. This most recent time I got the Aged to Perfection. It's a solid sandwich. A skosh on the pricy end for what it is but not outrageous for the area. I don't know that I agree that their medium size could feed 2 people but maybe if you're not so hungry. I do wish they offered options beyond whole & wheat bread (i.e. a wrap- when I asked about this I was told they had quesadillas which...obviously are not the same). Since I was the only person there the service was quick. But in review of the rest of the menu there really wasn't much else that made me want to come back. I think some of their sandwiches are interesting for the sake of being unique but maybe they could use some more just standard fare. And the location itself is a bit difficult to get to. It's directly next to a police precinct and a busy apartment area, so the parking can be difficult.

Carina H.
Carina H.

The sandwiches here truly are stacked. You get the most satisfying bite! The Stacked BST had a combination of ingredients that made for the most comforting, simple flavors. The bread is nice and toasty as well. The staff who helped us out was conversational and friendly. There's just something nice about a clean, local-feeling sandwich shop. This is more of a to-go place, but this place is worth stopping by!

Carin R.
Carin R.

It's just one of those places you want to keep for yourself but know you need to share it. Stacked offers a great selection of sandwiches and salads along with build your own options. The staff is super friendly and accommodating if you would like suggestions or substitutions they are happy to help. Cute sub shop feel but heads up: pick-up only, no spot to eat.

Haley R.
Haley R.

I ordered thru UberEats. I got the Italian Hottie (January specialty sandwich) and some chips. Arrived quickly and well packaged. It was sooooo good. I can't believe it took me so long to try this spot and I can't wait to try other things.

Jessica B.
Jessica B.

As someone who doesn't eat much meat, it's surprising how much I like Stacked. First, the staff here is great. Everyone is has been super friendly every time I've gone. Sandwich-wise, I like their salads. I didn't know chickpea salad was a thing until I had it here, and I love it. Their egg salad is also pretty good, too. I also really like their overnight oats. The PBJ oats are great, and the apple-cinnamon ones run a close second. I'll also add, while I haven't tried them, my husband has ordered actual heroes from them before. They are literally "stacked" and he thoroughly enjoys them. While it's a little off the beaten path of Forest Hills village (Austin and Yellowstone), it's definitely a great spot to check-out if you're in the mood for a sandwich.

Bianca C.
Bianca C.

I finally got a chance to come back to this gem but this time I brought my daughter along with me. I ordered a vegan steak again because it was AMAZING and my daughter ordered a build your own turkey, bacon club. All of the staff here are so attentive and nice the sandwiches are huge no matter what size you get, they all taste really good. They have so many drink options as I mentioned before one thing I did notice but didn't get to try before was the cold salads. My daughter got a chicken salad and I got the macaroni salad, Delicious. I did not have to add anything to my salad I felt that it was seasoned well. I have to come back and try another sandwich soon!!!!